Files
optimclaw/src/llm/CLAUDE.md
T
3da9810e87 feat(llm): Add OpenAI Codex (ChatGPT subscription) as LLM provider (#1461)
* feat(llm): add OpenAI Codex backend config and OAuth session manager

Add OpenAiCodex as a new LLM backend variant with config for auth
endpoint, API base URL, client ID, and session persistence path.

The session manager implements OpenAI's device code auth flow
(headless-friendly, no browser required on the server) with automatic
token refresh, following the same persistence pattern as the existing
NEAR AI session manager.

Closes #742

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 <[email protected]>

* feat(llm): add Responses API client and token-refreshing decorator

Native Responses API client for chatgpt.com/backend-api/codex/responses,
the endpoint that works with ChatGPT subscription tokens. Handles SSE
streaming, text completions, and tool call round-trips.

Token-refreshing decorator wraps the provider to pre-emptively refresh
OAuth tokens before API calls and retry once on auth failures. Reports
zero cost since billing is through subscription.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 <[email protected]>

* feat(llm): wire OpenAI Codex into provider factory, CLI, and setup wizard

Connect the new provider to the LLM factory, add openai_codex to the
CLI --backend flag, and add it as an option in the onboarding wizard.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 <[email protected]>

* fix(llm): address PR #744 review feedback (20 items)

Review fixes for the OpenAI Codex provider PR:

- Remove dead `generate_pkce()` code (device flow gets PKCE from server)
- Fix `refresh_tokens()` to use `.form()` instead of `.json()` per OAuth spec
- Inline codex dispatch into `build_provider_chain()` (single async function,
  no separate `assemble_provider_chain()` helper — matches main's pattern)
- Remove Clone from `OpenAiCodexSession`, restrict fields to `pub(crate)`
- Propagate HTTP client builder error instead of silent fallback
- Redact device code response body from debug log
- Change `set_model()` in TokenRefreshingProvider to delegate to inner
- Replace hardcoded `/tmp/` test path with `tempfile::tempdir()`
- Accept `request_timeout_secs` from config instead of hardcoded 300s
- Parse `Retry-After` header on 429 responses (matches nearai_chat.rs pattern)
- Reuse `normalize_schema_strict()` for Codex tool definitions
- Add warning log for dropped image attachments
- Add doc comments on `list_models()` and `include` field
- Add `OPENAI_CODEX_API_URL` to `.env.example`
- Fix codex error message in `create_llm_provider()` for clarity
- Revert unrelated `.worktrees` addition to `.gitignore`
- Update `src/llm/CLAUDE.md` with Codex provider docs

[skip-regression-check]

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 <[email protected]>

* fix: address review feedback and harden OpenAI Codex provider (takeover #744)

Security:
- Add SSRF validation (validate_base_url) on OPENAI_CODEX_AUTH_URL and
  OPENAI_CODEX_API_URL, matching the pattern used by all other base URL
  configs (regression test for #1103 included)

Correctness:
- Add missing cache_write_multiplier() and cache_read_discount() trait
  delegation in TokenRefreshingProvider
- Cap device-code polling backoff at 60s to prevent unbounded interval
  growth on repeated 429 responses
- Default expires_in to 3600s when server returns 0, preventing
  immediately-expired sessions
- Fix pre-existing SseEvent::JobResult missing fallback_deliverable field
  in job_monitor.rs tests

Cleanup:
- Extract duplicated make_test_jwt() and test_codex_config() into shared
  codex_test_helpers module

Co-Authored-By: Sanjeev-S <[email protected]>
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 (1M context) <[email protected]>

* fix: address PR review feedback on OpenAI Codex provider (#1461)

- Login command now resolves OPENAI_CODEX_* env overrides even when
  LLM_BACKEND isn't set to openai_codex (Copilot review)
- Setup wizard "Keep current provider?" for codex no longer re-triggers
  device code login — mirrors Bedrock's keep-and-return pattern (Copilot)
- Revert provider init log from info back to debug (Copilot)
- Add warning log when token expires_in=0, before defaulting to 3600s
  (Gemini review)

Co-Authored-By: Sanjeev-S <[email protected]>
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 (1M context) <[email protected]>

---------

Co-authored-by: Sanjeev Suresh <[email protected]>
Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.6 <[email protected]>
2026-03-20 08:14:20 -07:00

16 KiB

LLM Module

Multi-provider LLM integration with circuit breaker, retry, failover, and response caching.

File Map

File Role
mod.rs Provider factory (create_llm_provider, build_provider_chain); LlmBackend enum
config.rs LLM config types (LlmConfig, RegistryProviderConfig, NearAiConfig, BedrockConfig)
error.rs LlmError enum used by all providers
provider.rs LlmProvider trait, ChatMessage, ToolCall, CompletionRequest, sanitize_tool_messages
nearai_chat.rs NEAR AI Chat Completions provider (dual auth: session token or API key)
codex_auth.rs Reads Codex CLI auth.json, extracts tokens, refreshes ChatGPT OAuth access tokens
codex_chatgpt.rs Custom Responses API provider for Codex ChatGPT backend (/backend-api/codex)
openai_codex_provider.rs OpenAI Codex Responses API client (SSE streaming, JWT auth, subscription billing)
openai_codex_session.rs OAuth 2.0 session manager for OpenAI Codex (device code flow, token persistence)
token_refreshing.rs Token-refreshing LlmProvider decorator for OpenAI Codex (pre-emptive refresh, zero-cost billing)
reasoning.rs Reasoning struct, ReasoningContext, RespondResult, ActionPlan, ToolSelection; thinking-tag stripping; SILENT_REPLY_TOKEN
session.rs NEAR AI session token management with disk + DB persistence, OAuth login flow
circuit_breaker.rs Circuit breaker: Closed → Open → HalfOpen state machine
retry.rs Exponential backoff retry wrapper; is_retryable() classification
failover.rs FailoverProvider — tries providers in order with per-provider cooldown
response_cache.rs In-memory LLM response cache with TTL and LRU eviction (keyed by SHA-256)
costs.rs Static per-model cost table (OpenAI, Anthropic, local/Ollama heuristics)
rig_adapter.rs Adapter bridging rig-core CompletionModelLlmProvider; used by OpenAI, Anthropic, Ollama, Tinfoil
smart_routing.rs SmartRoutingProvider — 13-dimension complexity scorer routes cheap vs primary model
recording.rs RecordingLlm — trace capture for E2E replay testing (IRONCLAW_RECORD_TRACE)
bedrock.rs AWS Bedrock provider via native Converse API (feature-gated: --features bedrock)

Provider Selection

Set via LLM_BACKEND env var:

Value Provider Key env vars
nearai (default) NEAR AI Chat Completions NEARAI_SESSION_TOKEN or NEARAI_API_KEY
openai OpenAI OPENAI_API_KEY
anthropic Anthropic ANTHROPIC_API_KEY
ollama Ollama local OLLAMA_BASE_URL
openai_compatible Any OpenAI-compatible endpoint LLM_BASE_URL, LLM_API_KEY, LLM_MODEL
tinfoil Tinfoil TEE inference TINFOIL_API_KEY, TINFOIL_MODEL
bedrock AWS Bedrock (requires --features bedrock) BEDROCK_REGION, BEDROCK_MODEL, AWS_PROFILE
openai_codex OpenAI Codex (ChatGPT subscription) OPENAI_CODEX_MODEL, OPENAI_CODEX_CLIENT_ID

Codex auth reuse:

  • Set LLM_USE_CODEX_AUTH=true to load credentials from ~/.codex/auth.json (override with CODEX_AUTH_PATH).
  • If Codex is logged in with API-key mode, IronClaw uses the standard OpenAI endpoint.
  • If Codex is logged in with ChatGPT OAuth mode, IronClaw routes to the private chatgpt.com/backend-api/codex Responses API via codex_chatgpt.rs.
  • ChatGPT mode supports one automatic 401 refresh using the refresh token persisted in auth.json.

AWS Bedrock Provider

Uses the native Converse API via aws-sdk-bedrockruntime (bedrock.rs). Requires --features bedrock at build time — not in default features due to heavy AWS SDK dependencies.

Auth: Standard AWS credential chain — IAM credentials (AWS_ACCESS_KEY_ID/AWS_SECRET_ACCESS_KEY), SSO profiles (AWS_PROFILE), or instance roles. The SDK resolves auth automatically from the environment.

Config:

  • BEDROCK_REGION — AWS region (default: us-east-1)
  • BEDROCK_MODEL — Required model ID (e.g., anthropic.claude-opus-4-6-v1)
  • BEDROCK_CROSS_REGION — Optional cross-region inference prefix (us, eu, apac, global)

NEAR AI Provider Gotchas

Dual auth modes:

  • Session token (default): NEARAI_SESSION_TOKEN=sess_..., base URL = https://private.near.ai. Tokens are persisted to ~/.ironclaw/session.json (mode 0600) and optionally to the DB settings table (nearai.session_token). On 401 responses where the body contains "session" + "expired"/"invalid", NearAiChatProvider calls session.handle_auth_failure() which triggers the interactive OAuth login flow and retries once. Plain AuthFailed 401s are not retried.
  • API key: Set NEARAI_API_KEY (from cloud.near.ai), base URL defaults to https://cloud-api.near.ai. 401s with API key auth are immediately returned as LlmError::AuthFailed — no renewal.

Session renewal is interactive: When SessionExpired triggers renewal, it blocks and prompts the user in the terminal (GitHub/Google OAuth or manual API key entry). This is unsuitable for headless/hosted deployments — set NEARAI_SESSION_TOKEN env var instead.

Tool message flattening: NEAR AI's API doesn't support role: "tool" messages in the standard format. nearai_chat.rs defaults flatten_tool_messages = true, converting tool results to user messages with [Tool result from <name>]: <content> format. Use NearAiChatProvider::new_with_flatten(..., false) to disable for compliant endpoints.

Pricing auto-fetch: On startup, NearAiChatProvider fires a background task to fetch per-model pricing from /v1/model/list. If the fetch fails, it silently falls back to costs::model_cost() / costs::default_cost(). Pricing is stored in-memory only.

HTTP request timeout: The NEAR AI HTTP client has a 120-second timeout per request. Rate limit Retry-After headers are parsed (both delay-seconds and HTTP-date formats) and forwarded as LlmError::RateLimited { retry_after } for the RetryProvider to honor.

Circuit Breaker

State machine in circuit_breaker.rs:

Closed (normal)
  → Open (after failure_threshold consecutive transient failures; default: 5)
    → HalfOpen (after recovery_timeout; default: 30s)
      → Closed (after half_open_successes_needed probe successes; default: 2)
      → Open (if any probe fails)

Transient vs non-transient errors: Only RequestFailed, RateLimited, InvalidResponse, SessionExpired, SessionRenewalFailed, Http, and Io count toward the threshold. AuthFailed, ContextLengthExceeded, ModelNotAvailable, and Json errors never trip the breaker — they indicate caller problems, not backend degradation.

Configure via NearAiConfig fields: circuit_breaker_threshold (None = disabled), circuit_breaker_recovery_secs (default: 30).

The circuit breaker wraps the entire provider chain. When open, it immediately returns LlmError::RequestFailed with a message including remaining cooldown seconds. The FailoverProvider sitting outside can then try a fallback model.

Failover Chain

FailoverProvider in failover.rs wraps a list of LlmProvider instances. On a retryable error, it tries the next provider in the list. Providers that fail repeatedly enter a cooldown period and are skipped (unless all providers are in cooldown, in which case the least-recently-cooled one is tried).

Cooldown defaults: failure_threshold = 3 consecutive retryable failures → cooldown for cooldown_duration = 300s. Configure via NearAiConfig fields: failover_cooldown_secs, failover_cooldown_threshold.

Current wiring: The failover is set up between primary model and NEARAI_FALLBACK_MODEL (a different model name on the same NEAR AI backend), not across different LLM provider types. Cross-provider failover (e.g., NEAR AI → Anthropic) requires manual construction.

Retry

RetryProvider in retry.rs wraps any LlmProvider with exponential backoff. Retries on: RequestFailed, RateLimited, InvalidResponse, SessionRenewalFailed, Http, Io. Does not retry: AuthFailed, SessionExpired, ContextLengthExceeded, ModelNotAvailable, Json.

Backoff schedule: base 1s doubled per attempt with ±25% jitter, minimum floor 100ms. Attempt 0: ~1s, attempt 1: ~2s, attempt 2: ~4s. For RateLimited, uses the retry_after duration from the error (provider-supplied) instead of backoff.

Configure via NearAiConfig.max_retries (env: NEARAI_MAX_RETRIES; default: 3). Set to 0 to disable.

LlmProvider Trait

The full trait (all methods must be implemented or rely on defaults):

#[async_trait]
pub trait LlmProvider: Send + Sync {
    // Required
    fn model_name(&self) -> &str;
    fn cost_per_token(&self) -> (Decimal, Decimal);  // (input, output) per token
    async fn complete(&self, request: CompletionRequest) -> Result<CompletionResponse, LlmError>;
    async fn complete_with_tools(&self, request: ToolCompletionRequest) -> Result<ToolCompletionResponse, LlmError>;

    // Optional (have defaults)
    async fn list_models(&self) -> Result<Vec<String>, LlmError> { Ok(vec![]) }
    async fn model_metadata(&self) -> Result<ModelMetadata, LlmError> { /* name only */ }
    fn effective_model_name(&self, requested_model: Option<&str>) -> String { /* uses active */ }
    fn active_model_name(&self) -> String { self.model_name().to_string() }
    fn set_model(&self, _model: &str) -> Result<(), LlmError> { /* Err: not supported */ }
    fn calculate_cost(&self, input_tokens: u32, output_tokens: u32) -> Decimal { /* uses cost_per_token */ }
}

Key notes:

  • model_name() returns the configured model name; active_model_name() returns the currently active model (may differ if set_model() was called — only NearAiChatProvider supports this).
  • cost_per_token() returns (Decimal, Decimal) using rust_decimal. Look up via costs::model_cost() in your constructor; fall back to costs::default_cost() for unknowns.
  • RigAdapter ignores per-request model overrides (logs a warning). Only NearAiChatProvider supports per-request model overrides via CompletionRequest::model.
  • complete_with_tools() is never cached (tool calls can have side effects) — CachedProvider always passes them through.

To add a new provider:

  1. Create src/llm/myprovider.rs implementing LlmProvider
  2. Add variant to LlmBackend in mod.rs
  3. Wire into the factory match in mod.rs
  4. Add env vars to config/llm.rs and .env.example

Response Cache

CachedProvider in response_cache.rs caches complete() responses. complete_with_tools() is never cached (side effects). Cache key is SHA-256 of (model_name, messages_json, max_tokens, temperature, stop_sequences). LRU eviction when max_entries is reached; TTL-based expiry on access.

Defaults: TTL = 1 hour, max entries = 1000. Configure via NearAiConfig fields: response_cache_enabled (env: NEARAI_RESPONSE_CACHE_ENABLED), response_cache_ttl_secs, response_cache_max_entries. Cache is in-memory only — evicted on restart.

OpenAI-Compatible Custom Headers

Set LLM_EXTRA_HEADERS=Key:Value,Key2:Value2 to inject headers into every request. Useful for OpenRouter attribution (HTTP-Referer, X-Title). Invalid header names/values are skipped with a warning (not a fatal error).

OpenAI Codex Provider

Uses the Responses API at chatgpt.com/backend-api/codex/responses with ChatGPT subscription OAuth tokens (zero API cost — billing through subscription).

Auth flow: Device code OAuth via auth.openai.com/api/accounts/deviceauth/* endpoints. On first run, displays a code for the user to enter at a URL. Tokens are persisted to ~/.ironclaw/openai_codex_session.json (mode 0600) and auto-refreshed before expiry.

Provider chain: OpenAiCodexProviderTokenRefreshingProvider (pre-emptive refresh + retry on 401) → standard decorator chain. The TokenRefreshingProvider intercepts AuthFailed/SessionExpired errors, refreshes the OAuth token, and retries once.

Key differences from other providers:

  • Uses Responses API (not Chat Completions) — SSE streaming with different event types
  • System messages are sent as instructions field, not in input array
  • Tool schemas are normalized via normalize_schema_strict() for OpenAI strict mode
  • cost_per_token() returns (0, 0) — subscription-based billing
  • set_model() returns error — model is fixed at construction time
  • Image attachments are silently dropped with a warning log

Env vars: OPENAI_CODEX_MODEL (default: gpt-5.3-codex), OPENAI_CODEX_CLIENT_ID, OPENAI_CODEX_AUTH_URL, OPENAI_CODEX_API_URL.

Provider Chain Construction

build_provider_chain() in mod.rs is the single source of truth for assembling decorators. It creates the base provider (dispatching to create_openai_codex_provider() for codex, create_llm_provider() for everything else), then applies all decorators inline:

Raw provider
  → RetryProvider           (per-provider backoff; wraps both primary and fallback)
  → SmartRoutingProvider    (cheap/primary split when NEARAI_CHEAP_MODEL is set)
  → FailoverProvider        (fallback model; only when NEARAI_FALLBACK_MODEL is set)
  → CircuitBreakerProvider  (fast-fail; only when NEARAI_CIRCUIT_BREAKER_THRESHOLD is set)
  → CachedProvider          (response cache; only when NEARAI_RESPONSE_CACHE_ENABLED=true)
  → RecordingLlm            (trace capture; only when IRONCLAW_RECORD_TRACE is set)

build_provider_chain() also returns a separate standalone cheap LLM provider (for heartbeat/evaluation tasks — not part of the decorator chain).

reasoning.rs Contents

reasoning.rs does not contain an IntentClassifier. It contains:

  • Reasoning struct — the main reasoning engine used by the agent worker; calls complete_with_tools() and handles tool dispatch
  • ReasoningContext — carries messages, available tools, job description, and metadata into a reasoning call
  • RespondResult, ActionPlan, ToolSelection — output types from the reasoning engine
  • TokenUsage — input/output token counts
  • SILENT_REPLY_TOKEN ("NO_REPLY") and is_silent_reply() — used by the dispatcher to suppress empty responses in group chats
  • Thinking-tag stripping — regex-based removal of <thinking>, <reflection>, <scratchpad>, <|think|>, <final>, etc. from model responses before returning to the user

costs.rs Details

costs.rs provides a static lookup table (model_cost(model_id)) returning (input_cost, output_cost) per token as rust_decimal::Decimal. Provider prefixes like "openai/gpt-4o" are stripped before lookup. Returns None for unknown models — callers should fall back to default_cost() (roughly GPT-4o pricing). Local model heuristic (is_local_model()) returns zero cost for Ollama-style identifiers (llama*, mistral*, :latest, :instruct, etc.).

rig_adapter.rs Details

RigAdapter<M> bridges any rig-core CompletionModel to LlmProvider. It is actively used in production for all non-NEAR AI providers (OpenAI, Anthropic, Ollama, Tinfoil, OpenAI-compatible). Key behaviors:

  • Per-request model overrides are silently ignored (warning logged); the model is baked at construction time.
  • OpenAI strict-mode schema normalization is applied to all tool definitions: additionalProperties: false, all properties added to required, optional fields made nullable via "type": ["T", "null"]. This happens transparently at the provider boundary.
  • System messages are extracted into the rig-core preamble field (concatenated with newlines if multiple).
  • Tool call IDs are generated (generated_tool_call_{seed}) if the provider returns empty/whitespace IDs.
  • Tool name normalization: strips proxy_ prefix if it matches a known tool (handles some proxy implementations).
  • OpenAI uses Chat Completions API (completions_api()), not the newer Responses API — the Responses API path panics when tool results are sent back (rig-core doesn't thread call_id through ToolCall).

Streaming Support

No streaming support. All providers use non-streaming (blocking) Chat Completions requests. The complete() and complete_with_tools() methods return only after the full response is available.

Trace Recording

Set IRONCLAW_RECORD_TRACE=1 to enable live trace recording via RecordingLlm. Traces are JSON files containing: memory snapshot, HTTP exchanges from tools, and LLM steps (user inputs, text responses, tool call responses). Replay these in E2E tests via TraceLlm. Configure output path with IRONCLAW_TRACE_OUTPUT (default: trace_{timestamp}.json).